On May 26, Janice Lam was driving west on Beresford Street and planned to turn right at the intersection at Royal Oak Avenue, according to a ruling Thursday by B.C.’s Civil Resolution Tribunal.
Lam told the tribunal she’d made a full stop at the stop sign and saw a space between northbound vehicles on Royal Oak, which had been stopped by a flagger just north of the Beresford intersection.
She said she started slowly moving onto Royal Oak when she was side-swiped by another vehicle driven by Sheldon Schroeder.
A cyclist who saw the accident said Lam had stopped at the stop sign and then tried to “normally merge” after seeing a “reasonable opportunity.”
“(The cyclist) stated Mr. Schroeder became impatient in traffic and tried to force his way through, catching the corner of Ms. Lam’s vehicle,” states the tribunal ruling. “(The cyclist) stated the accident was ‘in slow motion’ because the vehicles were barely moving at the time.”
Schroeder described the accident differently.
He told the tribunal he had been proceeding slowly through the intersection when Lam, without stopping at the stop sign by Beresford, tried to turn right in front of him and then collided with his truck.
Dashcam video from his truck showed Lam had not, in fact, stopped at the stop sign but did stop before entering the intersection, according to the ruling.
The video shows the vehicles in front of Schroeder’s truck began moving forward while Schroeder was still stopped, creating a gap in front of him.
Lam tried to turn into that gap.
“Mr. Schroeder began moving his truck forward, and Ms. Lam stopped her vehicle,” the ruling states. “Both vehicles again came to a stop. As the vehicle in front of Mr. Schroeder again began to proceed, Ms. Lam continued her attempted right turn, while Mr. Schroeder’s truck remained stopped. After Ms. Lam started moving her vehicle, Mr. Schroeder progressed through the intersection, preventing Ms. Lam from continuing her turn. The front right corner of Mr. Schroeder’s truck and the front left corner of Ms. Lam’s vehicle ultimately collided at a very slow speed.”
Lam brought the case to the Civil Resolution Tribunal, claiming she suffered injuries and vehicle damage during the collision and seeking $5,627 for pain and suffering, $300 for her deductible and $2,650 for vehicle damage.
Tribunal vice chair Andrea Ritchie found that Lam had actually caused the accident by not yielding the right of way to Schroeder, who had already entered the intersection before she attempted to make her turn.
But the matter didn’t stop there.
Citing a B.C. Court of Appeal ruling, she said a driver with the right of way or “dominant driver” could share blame for an accident if it could be proven that driver “was aware or reasonably should have been aware of the servient driver’s disregard of the law.”
“Here, I find Mr. Schroeder was aware of Ms. Lam’s disregard of the law by failing to yield to his vehicle, and yet proceeded to try to prevent her from entering the intersection in front of him in any event,” Ritchie wrote. “I find Mr. Schroeder had ample opportunity to see that Ms. Lam was not yielding the right of way, and had ample opportunity to avoid the collision. Therefore, I find Mr. Schroeder was contributorily negligent for the accident.”
Ritchie assigned 65% of the blame to Lam and 35% to Schroeder.
She then ordered Schroeder to pay Lam a total of $1,938.63 in damages.